Ross McKeon gets it right, then gets it OH SO WRONG
Before I get going in a fit of controlled rage - here's your required reading of the day.
For those of you that don't know who he is, here's a little bit about Ross McKeon, from his own Yahoo Sports profile:
Ross McKeon covered the San Jose Sharks and the National Hockey League for 17 years at the San Francisco Chronicle and San Francisco Examiner. A chapter chairman for the Pro Hockey Writers' Association, he also has experience covering Major League Baseball and pro tennis. Ross graduated from California State University Hayward with a degree in Mass Communications.
If you wondered why McKeon's weekly rankings this season (and last season, and...) seemed to put the Sharks on top more often that not (even when they arguably deserved a lower ranking), well my friends - we have homers in high places.
Though homers can certainly get frustrated at times:
ANAHEIM, Calif. – There’s going to be a new rule in San Jose starting immediately. The words "Stanley Cup" are hereby banned from being uttered by anyone connected to the Sharks’ organization until the team wins a Western Conference title.
That’s it. No more. The franchise is not worthy to talk about something that appears so elusive. The Sharks should feel too embarrassed over what happened the last 10 days to ever fall into the trap of talking about winning a championship again.
And don’t hold your breath for the "Stanley Cup" ban to end. That Western Conference title is not right around the corner like fans have been led to believe time and time again.
Reactionary? Hell, I had this reaction after Game 4, so far be it from me to call the kettle black.
For the Sharks, it’s all California dreamin’. Empty words. All talk. Not enough action. The Sharks now know what the Ottawa Senators feel like.
One conclusion I derived from this paragraph is that the Mamas and the Papas' music should be banned from the HP Pavilion... especially given the eerie parallels between Mama Cass' demise and that of Team Teal this season (and last season, and...).
Another conclusion I derived is that I need to officially allow Pension Plan Puppets to say "I told you so." If only they didn't have photographic evidence of the sign I made... I'll burn that sucker this afternoon.
The enthusiastic fan base, criticized in the past for not being the most hockey savvy group, has come a long way and supported this franchise year after year. They are savvy now. And they are mad, as they should be.
They are sick and tired of listening to all the chatter, all the predictions. And they are sick of getting their hopes up. They, too, will not fall into this trap again.
Damn straight. Preach it, brother. Except that "not being the most hockey savvy group" - even if there was a commercial asking Sharks fans - in vain - what icing was (groan).
If Wilson can maneuver his way around no-trade clauses, my guess is three depart – Marleau, Cheechoo and Nabokov.
NABOKOV?!?
Yes, the goalie, too.
Hmmm... Let's start with his criticism of Captain Patrick Marleau:
Marleau is the captain, and ultimately it will be decided that leadership didn’t lead when needed most. The GM tried to surround Marleau, Thornton and the team’s top players with veterans who were also leaders. Leadership by committee would rule the day.
Marleau will be 30 when the next season starts. Eleven years a member of the Sharks, he has one year left at $6.3 million. They’ll be be lining up for his services; teams that don’t have to put the leadership tag on him yet are drooling for top-six forward help.
Ross, er, Mr. McKeon, the solution is very simple - someone else needs to step up into the Captain role, and MARLEAU NEEDS TO STAY PUT. He is the longest serving active Shark, as you hint at - but he need not bear the burden of the "C."
I'm a Patrick Marleau-homer, admittedly, but you're psycho-crazy-reactionary-in-the-extreme if you think Marleau should be jettisoned. Thirty-eight goals, 33 assists (71 points). Versatile enough to play 98% of the season as a left wing, when his forte is as center. Talking to coaches again. The only Shark to have game-winning goals in this series (2) - and you want to end that NOW.
Ahem.
However, we agree with you on Jonathan Cheechoo:
With two years at $3.5 million per season remaining on his contract, Cheechoo is too expensive of a third-line winger, and he can’t be productive there anyway. He’s not fast enough to play among San Jose’s top six, but he’d be attractive to another team with less depth.
The FTF staff and members have talked about this before - we are resigned to it. With the rising salaries of Douglas Murray and Marc-Edouard Vlasic, and the RFA situation with Joe Pavelski and Ryane Clowe, Jonathan Cheechoo has seen his last game as a Shark. If he IS around next year, then the "fire Doug Wilson" nonsense actually might sound halfway credible.
And now for our beloved Evgeni Nabokov, the Vezina Finalist of yesteryear:
Nabokov is the tough one. He’ll be 34 this summer, and he’s moving past his prime. He has one year left at $6 million. San Jose’s goaltending prospects aren’t ready to assume Nabokov’s job yet, so the team would have to acquire a starter.
Tell Nikolai Khabibulin (two years older than Nabby) he's past his prime and not worth his $6+ million, when everyone wrote off the Chicago netminder and his salary before the season started.
Simply put - it is INSANE to recommend ditching Nabokov... unless Steve Mason suddenly becomes available. Ahem.
I say that with all due respect, Mr. McKeon.
Sincerely,
Mr. K.
This item was created by a member of this blog's community and is not necessarily endorsed by Fear The Fin.
1 recs |
26 comments
Comments
My thoughts exactly
when I read that this morning. Good at the beginning, not so good there with the reactionary trade talk.
by Chicago Shark on Apr 28, 2009 11:59 AM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I was actually pretty disappointed (side note, I can never spell that fucking word right the first time; 2 p’s and 1 s, stupid) with Nabby’s play this series and I thought the real difference in the series was the play of the two goalies. That said, I don’t know about trading Nabby. It’s a bit reactionary to a 6 game sample.
When I was a kid I used to pray every night for a new bicycle. Then I realized God doesn’t work that way, so I stole one and prayed for forgiveness. - Emo Philips
Proud father of Juan Carlos Perez. Think Albert Pujols at second.
by marcello on Apr 28, 2009 12:11 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
I had forgotten about the sign. Feel free to check out the front page ;)
Pension Plan Puppets: A Toronto Maple Leafs blog and a group therapy session.
by PPP on Apr 28, 2009 12:16 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
OUCH
Fear The Fin = Anyone who doesn’t like fighting in the NHL can go watch poker on ESPN. [Jamie Baker]
by Mr. K. on Apr 28, 2009 12:49 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
And this is why I’m avoiding all hockey news cept for FTF and BoC today. I don’t need to read any crap that anyone says bout the Sharks. I’ve seen them all season. Every fucking game (okay, minus the ones not on tv, but then there were streams and radio). I’ve seen them in seasons past. I don’t need to hear anyone else’s fucking damn pathetic opinion of what needs to happen. I don’t need to hear someone say fans are upset, or a fan say they resigned themselves to it, or they are over being upset. It’s all fucking blah anyways. It’s all people spouting their own fucking opinions (just as I am now). And I don’t give a shit.
Bottom line, I’m depressed. Team didn’t get as far as I thought they were capable of. And it’s my problem to deal with. They whys of it is irrelevent. Next year I’ll be trying to buy tickets to the first home game like always and doing what I always do, cheering on the Sharks. Today, I’m going to wallow in this depression and fuck everyone else that tells me not to.
Ever get the feeling we are on a collision course with reality?
by ang6666 on Apr 28, 2009 12:21 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
as long as you don't make me wallow with you
you and I are golden.
I’m staying away from media coverage as well. Like I need to read the same stuff AGAIN.
resident cartoonist @couchtarts.blogspot.com
by CTGray on Apr 28, 2009 12:58 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Today, I’m going to wallow in this depression and fuck everyone else that tells me not to.
You might want to be careful with how you word this.
When I was a kid I used to pray every night for a new bicycle. Then I realized God doesn’t work that way, so I stole one and prayed for forgiveness. - Emo Philips
Proud father of Juan Carlos Perez. Think Albert Pujols at second.
by marcello on Apr 28, 2009 1:30 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
ZING!
Fear The Fin = Anyone who doesn’t like fighting in the NHL can go watch poker on ESPN. [Jamie Baker]
by Mr. K. on Apr 28, 2009 1:32 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
hmmmm and it’s usually me that can find the pervertedness in other’s statements.
Ever get the feeling we are on a collision course with reality?
by ang6666 on Apr 28, 2009 1:38 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'm with you two
I read Pollack’s last night…but I’m not interested in reading anything else except FTF. Gimme a month or 3 and I might start
Fear the Fin....where being an old guy isn't all bad, and the 2nd round can be bad on the heart
by Dave Valentine on Apr 28, 2009 4:10 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I agree with Mr. K- well done
Boyle ‘C’, Thornton ‘A’, Marleau ‘A’
Giving Boyle the ‘C’ is so obvious to me it hurts. Marleau is a great player and trading him would really tick me off, but his demeanor- the one he was born with- is not what this particular team needs from it’s ‘C’. We need a guy like Boyle who will say what needs to be said “To a man, they were better than us. Their goalie was better than ours. Their forwards were better than ours. Their D was better than ours.” Not Marleau’s quiet-spoken “It’s disappointing.”
If Patrick will sulk at losing the ‘C’, as one blogger indicated, then unfortunately for all of us Marleau fans, it’s time to move on without him. I suspect a Marleau ‘C’ apologist will call this blasphemy, but hey, when you think of a true ‘C’, do you think of Messier or Marleau in terms of demeanor? You know the answer.
by takesolace on Apr 28, 2009 12:36 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Boyle ‘C’, Thornton ‘A’, Marleau ‘A’
Heh, at first I thought you were giving letter grades.
But yeah, in terms of captaincy, that makes some sense. If Thornton-Marleau continue to be linemates, though, you may want to consider giving one of their ’A’s to a second- or third-liner or a depth d-man. Nice to have a ref-talkin’ representative out there in most situations of a game.
http://www.battleofcali.com/
by Earl Sleek on Apr 28, 2009 12:55 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Finally
Somebody on my side… Ha ha
by SetoThorMarChooSki on Apr 28, 2009 2:29 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
I'm going to withhold judgment on Nabby for a lil while
I see no benefit in trading Joe or Patty. Cheechoo might stay because no one wants to take on that salary for that production, but he may not fit anymore (though a Cheechoo-Couture-Mitchell line does raise an eyebrow for me).
Nabby . . . ughh, I like him. I really do. I told my fiance this after the loss, he plays like how I used to play goalie in soccer. Makes incredible save after incredible save, then boom, a mediocre goal (his problem is 5 hole, mine was holding on to crosses). So I sympathize with him . . . but I didn’t bring the additional weight of a huge contract as a burden on the team. If Nabby was making 2.5-3 mil a year, that’s great. He can be our Martin Biron or Dwayne Roloson. But we all expect him to be a notch below Brodeur or Luongo at $5 mil, and I don’t think he has ever been that kind of player, even last year. So, I think Nabby may go, but not because he isn’t good enough to take the team to the promised land, but solely because there is a more efficient distribution of resources.
Of course, that leaves a huge hole. Boucher played well, and if the Red Wings can win with Osgood, surely the Sharks can win with Boucher, but is that the best course? Can Greiss be our Hiller?
As for the C, I don’t know who should get it. I guess if Mike Modano can get the C taken away, anyone can. But if I remember correctly, Modano was pissed, yet nobody now questions his character.
by ruben398 on Apr 28, 2009 12:45 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Make a goalie decision after the Sharks settle the $$ on the RFA situation
Goaltending was a problem in the series, but lack of offensive production, leadership, faceoff wins, turnovers and more turnovers led to Sharks goals and Sharks losses. Can you believe that Vlasic was a -6?!
Nabby had a pretty good regular season, and never really has had this reputation of being a playoff underachiever until Anaheim. Even in Calgary and Dallas last year, he was making great saves at critical times of the game. In the Dallas series, we can blame it on Brian Campbell for that dumbfuck penalty he took. Point being, is regardless if you intend to play a $5 million keeper or a $1 million keeper, you still need a quality group of defensemen and forwards in front. Very few goalies Hasek, Luongo can make do without either— Nabokov is not one of those goalies. Which is no discredit to his play or achievements, but even Brodeur played behind Scott Stevens and Niedermayer when he won those Cups; and since they’ve left he hasn’t been to the conference finals. Khabibulin will be a UFA after this season, but he’s not really a significant upgrade in goal over Nabby. Manny Fernandez- nope. Dwayne Roloson— a Sharks killer, played very well despite a horrible team, but too old. Kari Lehtonen— that’s an intriguing situation. He’s an RFA however. Overall, I’d keep Nabby for next year.
Sharks to re-sign:
Clowe
Mitchell
Goc (if he can be had for cheap as a 4th line center. pretty good faceoff man)
Thomas Greiss (I think it might be ready to give him a shot in the big leagues again)
Boucher (we can do with or without. Substitute Greiss for Bouch)
Sharks players to reluctantly trade or not re-sign:
Mike Grier
J Cheechoo
Claude Lemieux (that was an epic failure)
Alex Semenov
K Huskins
Rob Blake (if we can get him for less than $4 million/yr)
One of Thornton or Marleau (not b/c I think it’s best for the team, but b/c DW will be pressured to do so)
Where hockey injuries in San Diego are thumb blisters from playing too much NHL 09
by Will Bulldozer on Apr 28, 2009 1:35 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Mc Keown's on the right track here...
I’m going to let this simmer for a few weeks but my gut tells me that Nabby must go…he’s starting to look rather average. Too bad we unloaded all of our top goaltending talent Kipper, Toscala, et al….not sold on Boucher either, once it went bad for him, he was like a sieve.
Marleau is a talented player, but he definately should not wear the ‘C’ and possibly should be traded.
Thornton the same although for some non – tangible reason I feel like it would be a big mistake to trade him.
Sick of everyone giving this team excuses – it’s all about the playoffs in Hockey and the Sharks choke in the playoffs consistently.
MAJOR CHOKE JOB…
Call me a troll or a Debbie Downer, don’t care. I am a fan of hockey and the Sharks from before blogs ever existed and I know what I see and what I don’t see with this team.
I see a team that chokes in the playoffs, and I don’t see anything changing until some heads roll.
SICK of this bullshit – and totally agree that the words Stanley Cup should not be uttered by anybody in this franchise until the Sharks can prove that they can win the Conference Finals first.
Bunk, bunk, bunk, bunk….Get your effin S*&t together Sharks!!!
You may now resume your regularly scheduled candy coating of this years Sharks playoff failure.
by GeeEssDub on Apr 28, 2009 1:53 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Too bad we unloaded all of our top goaltending talent Kipper, Toscala, et al….
Read the eulogy of the Calgary Flames - they rip Kipper mercilessly, with stats galore to back it up.
Fear The Fin = Anyone who doesn’t like fighting in the NHL can go watch poker on ESPN. [Jamie Baker]
by Mr. K. on Apr 28, 2009 2:17 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
fine....
Kipper may not have been “the answer” but Nabby (and Boucher) aren’t either. I even liked that Shaefer kid we had in the minors they traded. We’re supposed to be deep at the goaltending position in our minor league system, right?
At least we used to be….
Who the eff knows at this point, just know we choked like dogs
by GeeEssDub on Apr 28, 2009 3:06 PM PDT reply actions 0 recs
Yes but
Greiss or Sexsmith definitely need a year or two before they even should be seeing intermittent starts for San Jose.
The fat lady is clearing her pipes. Time to shove some corn down her throat.
by joe579 on Apr 28, 2009 6:55 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
We have goaltending depth
But all of the players are at least a few seasons away from being ready to be a starter. Greiss finally got his first professional shutout late this season, and has since gone on a tear, backstopping the WorSharks to the second round. Sexsmith set all sorts of records in the WHL, and backstopped his team to the Western Conference Finals. There’s Harri Sateri, who at 19 is playing professionally in Sweden; Stalock had a great year with UMD and just signed a contract with Worcester; and Dakers, who posts respectable numbers but might lose his backup job in Worcester to Stalock.
All these goalies were drafted 2004 and later, meaning that they’re still pretty young. And all are on the top 20 prospects list for the Sharks on Hockey’s Future, so take that as you may.
by mymclife on Apr 28, 2009 9:15 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Schaefer was really a flash in the pan
5 good games in the NHL doesn’t make up for that he is a 1B AHL goalie.
I’d like Sexsmith to be called up just so I could hear Randy Hahn say “What a sexy save!”
Nabby has 1 more year to go on his contract. Regardless of what this fluke playoff series showed, he’s still one of the better goalies in the NHL and only 1 year removed from being a Vezina finalist. There’ll be few proven goalies that are UFAs or RFAs in July. Might as well let Sexsmith or Greiss develop and play your cards then. Sharks have bigger issues than goaltending to sort out.
Where hockey injuries in San Diego are thumb blisters from playing too much NHL 09
by Will Bulldozer on Apr 28, 2009 10:44 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
agreed
let Nabby play for one more year, he is still by all means a good goalie and in a contract year could be a Vezina finalist
by Brian5517209 on Apr 29, 2009 8:08 AM PDT up reply actions 0 recs
Once Sexsmith is here...
I will be the first to purchase a jersey.
And a replica helmet.
Fear the Fin: Where we just have to want it more!
by That'll Cheech You on Apr 29, 2009 1:05 PM PDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 

















