We’ve reviewed the schedule, talked tactics, examined the field, highlighted important players, focused on the goaltending matchup and peeked at the opposing roster. Now it’s time for us to lay down our predictions for the first-round series between the San Jose Sharks and Los Angeles Kings, set to finally begin at the Tank tonight at 7:30.
Projected Game 1 Lineups
Joe Pavelski – Joe Thornton – Brent Burns
Patrick Marleau – Logan Couture – Matt Nieto
Tomas Hertl – James Sheppard – Tommy Wingels
Raffi Torres – Andrew Desjardins – Mike Brown
Marc-Edouard Vlasic – Jason Demers
Brad Stuart – Justin Braun
Scott Hannan – Dan Boyle
Scratches: Marty Havlat, Tyler Kennedy, Matt Irwin
Marian Gaborik – Anze Kopitar – Justin Williams
Dwight King – Mike Richards – Jeff Carter
Dustin Brown – Jarret Stoll – Tyler Toffoli
Kyle Clifford – Trevor Lewis – Jordan Nolan
Jake Muzzin – Drew Doughty
Robyn Regehr – Slava Voynov
Willie Mitchell – Alec Martinez
Scratches: Tanner Pearson, Matt Greene
| Team | Score-Adj. Fenwick% | 5v5 GF/60 | 5v5 GA/60 | 5v5 Goal Differential | 5v4 SF/60 | 4v5 SA/60 | Usage Chart |
| San Jose | 54.6% | 2.44 | 2.14 | +20 | 63.7 | 43.7 | Link |
| Los Angeles | 56.7% | 2.06 | 1.62 | +28 | 51.4 | 49.4 | Link |
Infographic courtesy Brendan Sheridan. Click to embiggen.
Patrick: Nerd-vana. The best Fenwick Close team versus the third-best. Both teams employ effective forechecks and fluid transition games. Neither team plays a significant amount of defense. This will be an end-to-end slugfest. Everybody’s talking about us you guys (well, all the #fancystats people). L.A. plays a 2-1-2 split forechecking system that’s built on crushing defensemen. The Sharks’ D will need to move the puck quickly to avoid coughing it up deep behind the net and feeding great scoring opportunities. Please dear hockey gods, don’t let the coaching staff send out the Hannan/Stuart disaster. Demers, Vlasic, Boyle (especially), and Braun must be able to exit the zone in this one or it will be over quickly. The Sharks will feast on the corpse of Robyn Regehr and he’ll have a 100% target and 100% controlled entry against statline at the end of the series. Sharks in seven.
Jon W.: It’s a little unfair the conference championship is happening in the first round. But we might as well enjoy it now. These are two of the very best teams facing off, with rosters that are relatively healthy. With the current configuration of the Sharks’ bottom six, I could easily see the Kings stealing one of the first two games in San Jose. With their backs against the wall though, I think the Sharks will stick Pavelski back on line three and roll from there. James Sheppard (as 4th line left wing) scores the series clinching goal. Sharks in seven.
Mike: Dustin Brown does a knee-on-knee with Jonathan Quick’s goalpost and tears his ACL. Sharks in four.
Jake S.: Two months ago I would have had the Sharks in six, but given what has happened since then I feel…well, differently about the way this series is going to work out. The Kings have problems on offense, but my pessimism about the Sharks these days on defense and in goal outweigh that. Kings in six.
Nick: Sharks fans are feeling pretty pessimistic about this match-up because, frankly, pessimism is how we approach postseason hockey. If you recall, the Kings and Sharks played a tense seven-game series a year ago that ended with a 2-1 victory for the home team at Staples. Since then, LA has put together another season of dominating possession hockey, leading the NHL with a 56.7% Fenwick Close, and getting strong goaltending from Jonathan Quick (0.928 Sv% at 5-on-5). Unsurprisingly, the Kings were the toughest team in the league to score on this season. As such, the arguments for optimism in San Jose look something like this:
- If any team has an offense dynamic enough to break down the Kings, it’s the Sharks, especially with a healthy Tomas Hertl on the ice.
- There’s a reason the Kings fell to third in the Pacific after a long skid in December and January: no team in the playoffs this year scored fewer goals than LA, and only the Buffalo Sabres had a lower even-strength Sh% than the Kings’ 6.6%. If they can’t find the back of the net against Antti Niemi, the Kings’ presumed advantage in possession isn’t going to matter.
- Quick is a career 0.915 goalie. At some point, the Statistical Regression Fairy is bound to point in his direction in a playoff series.
Sharks in seven.
Jake B.: Welp, this one’s a toughie. Just a few weeks ago, I was telling you all how SJ had to make some serious changes if they wanted to beat the Kings. In the final game of the season, those changes were made, however if the lines they ran in practice yesterday are correct, then those changes have not been made. That certainly doesn’t make me feel good about this series, but I’ll keep my blind optimism as to our chances against the Kings, as well as TMac’s coaching alive, and hope that those changes eventually are put into place, and we can kick the best team in the NHL out of the Stanley Cup race in the first round. Sharks in seven.
Derek: I’m certainly a lot more optimistic about this series than I was at this time a week ago before Tomas Hertl made his triumphant return and Raffi Torres was more or less confirmed to be available for Game 1. On paper, I truly believe the Sharks have a roster capable of beating the Kings, unlike a year ago. I’m less confident in their level of health and in the coaching staff’s ability not to screw this up by trotting out James Sheppard as the third-line center and playing Mike Brown in favor of Marty Havlat or Tyler Kennedy. If Todd McLellan has his come-to-Jesus moment early on in this series and ices the lineup that gives the Sharks the best chance to win, I think they’ll pull this off. If that never happens, or doesn’t occur until it’s too late, the Kings will be triumphant once again. I’ll guess that Hertl forces McLellan’s hand pretty quickly, so Sharks in seven.
Ann: Screw Dustin Brown. Sharks in six.
How will this series end?
| Sharks in four | 35 |
| Sharks in five | 94 |
| Sharks in six | 236 |
| Sharks in seven | 162 |
| Kings in four | 4 |
| Kings in five | 7 |
| Kings in six | 47 |
| Kings in seven | 22 |
